© Copyright 2002
Rogers Media. The following article first appeared in the January 2002 edition
of BENEFITS CANADA magazine.
Benefits Trends
Preventive
medicine
We need to focus on disease prevention, not
paying for treatments. A new wellness study demonstrates the value of a
proactive approach.
By Kathryn Dorrell
Benefits manager geoff kerr calls his
company's participation in a recent wellness study a much-needed "wake-up call."
Almost half of Ocean Contractors' 200 employees in Dartmouth, N.S., took part in
Project Impact--a cardiovascular initiative aimed at reducing heart attacks and
strokes--and most of them were taken aback by the results.
"They had no idea of what their
blood pressure or cholesterol levels were," says Kerr. "It took a face-to-face
health screen to [get across] the stark reality."
Kerr adds that the three-month program had a "huge
impact" on employees' living habits. He also readily acknowledges that this will
have a positive effect on the health of the organization as well as its future
benefits' expenses.
Project Impact involved employees from eight
organizations. Individuals with at least two modifiable risk factors (smoking,
weight, high blood pressure and/or cholesterol and inactivity) underwent a
health assessment and intervention program, including exercise, weight
management and smoking cessation.
After just three months, employees were re- evaluated and
there was a "massive improvement" in cardiovascular health, says Dr. Lydia
Makrides, director of the Atlantic Health & Wellness Institute in Halifax.
All major risk factors had decreased notably and 40% of the smokers had kicked
the habit without medication.
The most important lesson emerging from Project Impact is
the value of preventive medicine. "We [employers] talk about compensation and
providing for the future, but we don't talk a lot about a healthy lifestyle and
it can't help reduce [benefits] costs," says Kerr. Indeed, heart disease--the
No. 1 driver of healthcare costs in organizations and the public system--is
preventable in 80% to 90% of cases involving working-age citizens, adds Dr.
Makrides.
The value of a proactive approach to healthcare is
evident in the return on investment data from the study. For every $1 invested
in Project Impact (funded by Atlantic Blue Cross, Aventis Pharma and the
Atlantic Health and Wellness Institute), there is a minimum return of $1.64 for
the employer. For plan members with three risk factors, the return is $2.04. It
jumps to $3.93 for blue-collar workers. The returns include projected
disability, absenteeism and drug savings, but they do not incorporate savings to
the public system, which would make them even more impressive.
Despite the growing body of research on wellness
programs, the focus on health within the public system and in most
organizations, sadly, remains on a curative or reactive approach to health and
medicine. Most provincial healthcare plans don't pay for preventive health
practices.
At the employer level, things are better. But Makrides
points out the irony of plan sponsors using the term 'early intervention' when
they become involved in health management after an individual is already off
sick. "Then they start talking about stress management, etc.," she says.
Another case in point is a recent high blood pressure
study. It shows that Canadians are half as likely as U.S. individuals to have
the condition under control because we have failed to invest in disease
prevention, which is costing employers and the public system dearly, says David
Maclean, head of community health at Dalhousie University in Halifax and
co-author of a recent report on disease prevention.
The good news is that Makrides says employer attitudes
are starting to change. While wellness efforts were once a casualty of tough
economic times and benefits cutbacks, she believes they will weather the current
fiscal pressures on benefits plans.
"We simply cannot afford the healthcare that we have. The
time is right for the [preventive medicine] message. It is now a matter of when
[we do it] because unhealthiness in the workplace is simply too costly." For the
sake of workplace health, let's hope this assessment is right. BC
Kathryn
Dorrell is the managing editor of BENEFITS CANADA. kdorrell@rmpublishing.com
|