For years, New York lawmakers convicted of abusing their power who went off to prison had at least one thing to look forward to: a generous state pension.

That practice could come to an end in November when voters will consider whether to change the state constitution to authorize judges to strip pensions from corrupt politicians.

Top lawmakers and Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo have argued the change will act as a powerful deterrent in a state where 30 state lawmakers have left office since 2000 because of criminal charges or allegations of ethical misconduct.

Some good-government advocates question whether the loss of a pension will be enough to keep errant lawmakers honest. But in the face of decades of legislative inaction on ethics, even the critics say something is better than nothing.

“It’s in the chicken soup category — it can’t hurt,” said Blair Horner, executive director of the New York Public Interest Research Group. “Will it make much of a difference in Albany? No.”

Read: MP pensions face $1-billion shortfall: C.D. Howe

This isn’t the first such measure aimed at pensions. A 2011 law allowed judges to revoke or reduce pensions of crooked lawmakers but it didn’t apply to sitting politicians at the time. A constitutional amendment is necessary to cover all lawmakers, no matter when they took office. This year’s ballot question, if approved, will close that loophole.

There has been no opposition to the measure by any public official. The new rules, if approved by voters, would apply to all lawmakers going forward, although not to those already sentenced for previous crimes.

“I believe 100 per cent we should revoke the pension of any elected official who is found guilty of official corruption. I’m outraged as a taxpaying citizen,” Cuomo said when lawmakers first voted to place the constitutional amendment on the ballot.

About half of the states already have similar pension forfeiture laws on the books, although the laws and constitutional provisions governing the issue vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. California, Connecticut and Virginia allow for pension revocation when officials commit a crime related to their official duties. Some states spell out specific crimes, while others take a broader approach. In Oklahoma, for example, public officials can lose their pension for committing any felony.

Read: MPs and cabinet forced to reimburse pension overpayment

Calls to crack down on corruption in New York picked up momentum two years ago after both Democratic Speaker Sheldon Silver and Republican Senate Leader Dean Skelos were convicted of corruption (the convictions have since been reversed because of a U.S. Supreme Court verdict). Prosecutors intend to retry the men.

Regardless, the pensions they had coming for their years of service — nearly $100,000 a year for Skelos and $85,000 to $98,000 a year for Silver — were never at risk.

“Hardworking New Yorkers are getting screwed, paying into a system so corrupt politicians can enjoy six-figure pensions and walk free,” said Brandon Muir, director of the government watchdog group Reclaim New York.


Copyright © 2017 Transcontinental Media G.P. Originally published on

Add a comment

Have your say on this topic! Comments that are thought to be disrespectful or offensive may be removed by our Benefits Canada admins. Thanks!

* These fields are required.
Field required
Field required
Field required