Originally from our sister publication, SmallBizAdvisor.ca.

When a worker is an independent contractor and not an employee, there are important differences for an employer.

An employer is not required to deduct and remit to the government statutory payroll taxes and deductions such as income tax, Canada Pension Plan, Ontario Employer Health tax and employment insurance for independent contractors.

In addition, independent contractors are not covered under the Employment Standards Act, 2000, nor are they entitled to common law notice of termination.  This often makes the relationship more attractive for employers.

However, when hiring someone as an independent contractor, employers must ensure that the reality of the relationship is that of an independent contractor and not an employment relationship.

Although the intention of the parties is given some weight, it is only one factor the courts will take into account, and a statement in the contract will not be determinative.  The totality of the relationship must reflect the independence required to support a contract for service.

The courts (and the Canada Revenue Agency) have developed a four-part test to determine whether an employment relationship exists.  The key factors taken into account are:

  • Control (how much control the employer has over the worker’s activities);
  • Ownership of tools (generally, a contractor supplies his own tools, but this will depend upon the industry norms);
  • Chance of profit/risk of loss (the financial risk taken by the worker, such as investments in equipment and materials, and whether the worker can realize a profit); and
  • Integration into the employer’s business.

Health, dental and life insurance benefits add significant value to workers’ contracts and are often specifically sought out by workers.  However, the provision of these seemingly innocuous benefits can be problematic and can result in major legal ramifications if provided to contractors.

The provision of health and welfare benefits to a worker has been noted by the Tax Court of Canada as demonstrating a degree of control by the employer that suggests an employment relationship. Although this is one factor to be considered when assessing the relationship in its entirety, it could be the one to tip the scales towards an employment relationship.

There is no one conclusive “test” to be applied in determining whether a person is an employee or an independent contractor.

Courts will instead look at the totality of the relationship between the parties. Accordingly, employers should examine all aspects of their independent contractor relationships to determine whether they can satisfy the above tests, including the provision of benefits. Otherwise, the employer may be on the hook for significant, unanticipated costs.

Nadine Zacks is an associate lawyer at Hicks Morley’s Toronto office, currently practicing in all areas of labour and employment law.

Copyright © 2020 Transcontinental Media G.P. Originally published on benefitscanada.com

Join us on Twitter

See all comments Recent Comments

Auke Beerschoten:

CRA has determined (several years ago) that an Employer can extend their employee benefits to Independent Contractors, and if they collect all premiums (after tax), this will not affect the Independent Contractor status.

Friday, October 11 at 10:10 pm | Reply


This is interesting topic. I want insight into a situation where by I am receiving Ontario works benefits. Due to lockdown for COVID-19 pandemic I was recruited by an agency to work for food services in nursing homes for at least six shifts. Pay comes on May 15, 2020. Do I report the income to Ontario Works? Thanks

Sunday, May 10 at 9:50 am | Reply

Add a comment

Have your say on this topic! Comments that are thought to be disrespectful or offensive may be removed by our Benefits Canada admins. Thanks!

* These fields are required.
Field required
Field required
Field required