While compliance with requirements to file statements of investment policies and procedures has reached 94 per cent in Ontario, only 34 per cent of the filers incorporate environmental, social and governance factors into them.

The numbers are from a new report by the Financial Services Commission of Ontario. But Hugh O’Reilly, president and chief executive officer of OPSEU Pension Trust, says the relatively low number of reported filers that incorporate environmental, social and governance factors could be misleading.

“I think it’s easier for a plan administrator to say that the plan is not incorporating ESG factors than to say they are, because the next question is how, and that may take considerable resources to explain,” he says. “It’s a lot of extra work for a smaller plan, and that creates unwanted uncertainty.”

Read: What should plan sponsors expect around ESG reporting?

Indeed, O’Reilly believes most plans incorporate the factors, “even if they don’t do it explicitly.”

By contrast, OPTrust, a relatively large plan, does have the resources to meet the challenge and has long been an advocate of responsible investing. Its website sets out the pension fund’s policies in three detailed documents: a statement of investment policies and procedures, a statement of responsible investing principles and proxy voting guidelines.

The FSCO report follows on the requirement that administrators of Ontario-registered pension plans file a document setting out their key investment policies and procedures by Jan. 1, 2016. Each filing must contain an information summary that enunciates the key policies from each plan’s statement and serves as a checklist to ensure it’s compliant.

Read: Pension fund assets make up 75% of responsible investing in Canada: report

Pension administrators in the province filed 6,300 investment policy statements by July 31, 2016, according to the report, bringing compliance up to 82 per cent. Filing compliance at that point was highest among jointly sponsored (100 per cent) and multi-employer pensions plans (96 per cent). Single-employer (83 per cent) and individuals pension plans (77 per cent) lagged behind. Compliance by pension plans has since increased to 94 per cent as of June 30, 2017.

O’Reilly maintains the numbers demonstrate the government’s requirement to file an investment policy statement is a good one. “It forced administrators to focus on these important issues,” he says.

Indeed, FSCO estimates that a significant number of pension plans may not have had a statement before 2016. The regulator believes, however, that the mandatory filing requirement “may have led more plans to do so.”

When it comes to rates of return, the median expected was 3.5 per cent adjusted for inflation and 7.5 per cent on a nominal basis. “The smallest plans (those under $10 million in assets) reported on average a higher expected nominal [rate of return] than the largest pension plans (those with assets greater than $1 billion),” the report noted. “The difference was as high as 137 basis points.”

Read: Ontario plans tout ESG progress at responsible investment conference

Turning to governance, FSCO found 25 per cent of defined benefit plans and 10 per cent of defined contribution plans required plan administrators to monitor investment manager performance quarterly or more frequently. “Most SIPPs indicated that investment performance must be monitored ‘on at least an annual basis,’” the report noted.

Finally, the median number of investment funds offered in member-directed defined contribution plans was between 20 and 25, with the most common default options being life-cycle or target-date funds.

Editor’s note: Story updated Aug. 8 to revise the proportion of plans incorporating environmental, social and governance factors to 34 per cent from the earlier reported 36 per cent. FSCO has clarified that 34 per cent of plans reported incorporating the factors as of June 30, 2017, while 36 per cent had done so as of July 31, 2016. In addition, while the story initially reported compliance with requirements around investment policy statements as being 94 per cent as of July 31, 2016, the correct figure was 82 per cent at that point. The most recent compliance rate was 94 per cent as of June 30, 2017.

Copyright © 2020 Transcontinental Media G.P. Originally published on benefitscanada.com

Join us on Twitter

Add a comment

Have your say on this topic! Comments that are thought to be disrespectful or offensive may be removed by our Benefits Canada admins. Thanks!

* These fields are required.
Field required
Field required
Field required